Is this even a question? Demi.
their voices sound alike. Carrie did better on consistence.Demi wins above e5.
Demi any day
Demi's got better technique and knows how to mix properly. If the playing field was more leveled in regards to that, Carrie would win imo since her voice is a bit richer than Demi's. Btw if you're interested in ever revamping this video or using Carrie in another video, let me know because I can let you know which songs contain her best belts for each note.
Anyway Hoosier, if you ever decide to revamp or do a part 2 of this video, or even just feature Carrie in any other video, here are her best studio belts imo. Hope it helps! I have it set to automatically go to the exact point in the video in which each note is sung.
D5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPYDioerpdY#t=3m58s (she does background vocals on this one)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZ2kdx4zZUY#t=3m17shttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9O3KOKQynm8#t=1m37s
Eb5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCQsnaHdVRU#t=1m58shttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCQsnaHdVRU#t=2m10s (phrased)
E5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BHxsXC1f-wE#t=2m39shttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0G5SvO1CXQY#t=2m52s (phrased)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0G5SvO1CXQY#t=2m59s (phrased)
What is the song where Carrie phrased the f5?
Thanks both of you.:)
C5 (Both) – DemiD5 (1) – CarrieD5 (2) – DemiEb5 (Both) – DemiE5 – I wanna say Demi but I think they were pretty evenF5 (1) – DemiF5 (2) – Carrie (These are my favourite from her)F#5 – CarrieOverall I think Demi won (8-4), nice video!
I do prefer 2015 Demi but Carrie is more versatile and consistent and her F#5 was amazing. Her metallic tone isnt to my taste I guess.
Although I liked Carrie before I like Demi I have to say Demi won this.
CARRIE UNDERWOOD ❤❤
As good as Demi is, it's just unfair to put anyone in a belting battle with Carrie Underwood. The woman could stop a moving train with an E5.
C5: TieC#5: DemiD5-Eb5: CarrieE5: TieF5: DemiF#5: Carrie
So I guess they tie here. But Live, Carrie eviscerates her from the whole 4th octave all the way to E5/F#5. Although, I do think the better overall singer is Demi..but she's still got a whole bunch of things to iron out vocally.
Are you kidding me? Carrie totally slays, she is a totally above Lovato.
Demi's technique is a bit better but carrie's instrument destroys demi, and though carrie have flawed vibrato (very wide, wobbly) atleast it comes of naturally and my ears can tolerate it 😂 unlike demi's oh my fucking god she should stop that fake vibrato ASAP! It's the worst and the most unatural vibrato i heard i swear to death! and she should start working on how to stabilize her vocal line..her legato is so choppy
Demi all the way!
demi killed it carrie tries too hard for my opinion
Carrie is more versatile and has a beautiful tone
Of course Carrie wins
C a r r i e
O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *
Por Favor Faça a entrada em nosso site é gratis